Medical Services | Health Information | Appointments | Education and Research | Jobs | About

Connect with an expert

Pregnancy and you blog

With Mayo Clinic certified nurse-midwife Mary Murry, R.N., C.N.M.
Back to posting index
June 3, 2008
Even the best birth plans don't always work out
5 comments posted
Read comments | Post a comment
By Mary Murry, R.N., C.N.M.

In my last blog I encouraged everyone to have a birth plan. Now you're thinking "Fine Mary, I had a plan and nothing happened as I planned. What do I do now?"

Many things can happen that make your birth plan nothing more than a piece of paper. You might come in with active labor and find out your baby is breech and a Cesarean delivery is required. You might find that you have a medical condition or pregnancy complication that requires labor induction when induction was never mentioned in your plan.

It is possible that you wanted low lights and quiet during labor and instead it is the busiest night of the year in labor and delivery and all the loud people are on and someone keeps turning on your room lights! The birth plan may state that a medication-free childbirth is desired. I have known some women that felt they were almost pressured into having an epidural when they really could have gone the distance with more active support and encouragement.

There are also those women who planned for an epidural but were told they were too far along for one and would have to go without anything. A woman can feel disappointed, frustrated, even very angry when their birth plan seems to be ignored or made light of. These feelings can be intensified when we feel that no one explained why things went the way they did, why things didn't go as we had planned. If this happens to you, I think the most important thing you can do is communicate your feelings to the appropriate people. Do it as soon as possible. It might not be immediately.

You may find that it is only several weeks after the birth that you are able to process all that happened. Letters can be written to hospitals, unit managers or supervisors. If your health care provider contributed to your feelings, you should try to express this to them. Everyone needs feedback. Healthcare providers can be unaware of the impact actions or attitudes can have on a woman and family during labor and birth.

Some women feel guilty because they did not do what they had planned. We can't always meet our expectations about how we will deal with labor and birth. As much as we would like to, we can't predict how we will deal with this one of a kind experience.

Try to remember that your birth plan was a plan printed on paper for a unique and unpredictable event. Don't let it cloud the miracle of your child's birth day.

5 comments posted
Read comments | Post a comment
Back to posting index
July 1, 2008 11:01 p.m.
Gee, it was 27 years ago but still aggravates me. I have early onset osteoarthritis in my hips and never could get my feet in those stirrups even at age 16. So at 35 for the birth of my first and only child, I worried about it and communicated this in advance but two different nurses insisted on trying even though I insisted there was no way it would happen. It was and still is most embarrassing to me as they wouldn't listen. Luckily my physician arrived who was willing to allow me natural childbirth any way that worked! Piece of cake!
- MaryJane
June 18, 2008 5:47 a.m.
Excellent information - I'll have to post a link to it on my post about having a birth plan. Marijke www.wombwithin.com
- Marijke
June 9, 2008 12:46 p.m.
Nice Post. Posted this link in www.surfurls.com .Its a social bookmarking site.
- gibsy
June 4, 2008 8:47 a.m.
"A woman can feel disappointed, frustrated, even very angry when their birth plan seems to be ignored or made light of. These feelings can be intensified when we feel that no one explained why things went the way they did, why things didn't go as we had planned....Don't let it cloud the miracle of your child's birth day." Not only do I agree with the pp that a cesarean is always represented as "required" for a breech baby and that this attitude inteferes with a woman's ability to make an informed choice, but I amo also concerned with the implication that a woman chooses to "let" the events of her birth "cloud" her early days of motherhood. Many women are traumatized by the lack of communication from careproviders in addition to the violation of certain "procedures" in childbirth, whether necessary or not. These feelings are very real. Research has shown that as many as 25-33% of women perceive their births to be traumatic. No matter how noble the intent, it is harmful to imply that women choose to feel traumatized.
- Christie
June 4, 2008 1:33 a.m.
I'm always dismayed by the words "breech" and "cesarean required" in the same sentence. Breech babies are not an indication for cesarean delivery and the most recent research just reaffirms that cesareans are not protective vs vaginal birth. I know you are focusing your efforts at encouraging women to understand that things may change during labor, but I think it's more productive to not buy into false dichotomies. Encouraging women to be an equal part and the GUIDING force of her health care rather than having to deal with the aftermath of trauma due to expectations that were often sabotaged by the hospital system within which they are birthing. There is no reason to accept cesarean=breech any more than there is reason to accept any other physician-protective defensive medicine techniques. Women need to learn to weigh the information and make choices. Not just hand over a plan and think that somehow protects them, but actually believe that they have the rights to informed and FULL consent and informed and FULL refusal of procedures. Perhaps the most disturbing trend in recovery from birth trauma is that women feel badly because their choices were co-opted or they were lied to , coerced or not given full informed consent to realize later that this cost them their plans for birth.
- Shanon
Post a comment

PREGNANCY AND YOU


Nov 21, 2008