• image.alt
  • With Mayo Clinic nutritionists

    Jennifer Nelson, M.S., R.D. and Katherine Zeratsky, R.D.

    read biography

Mayo Clinic Health Manager

Get free personalized health guidance for you and your family.

Get Started

Free

E-Newsletter

Subscribe to receive the latest updates on health topics. About our newsletters

  • Housecall
  • Alzheimer's caregiving
  • Living with cancer
  • Nutrition-wise blog

  • Feb. 3, 2009

    Part 2: For those with diabetes — there's more to it than carbs

    By Jennifer Nelson, M.S., R.D. and Katherine Zeratsky, R.D.

26 comments posted

I'm glad to see the responses — and the strong opinions expressed thus far — to last week's blog.

Indeed the January 2008 "American Journal of Clinical Nutrition" analysis of diets from the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial presents striking findings that challenge some long-held assumptions. The study showed that diets lower in carbohydrates — and higher in total fat and saturated fat — resulted in need for higher insulin doses and worse glycemic control in people with type 1 diabetes. The study did not look at those with type 2 diabetes.

It's worth stepping back and looking at some nutrition basics. Diets are constructed by varying the amounts of four calorie-providing nutrients: carbohydrates, protein, fat and alcohol. Reducing one component — for example carbohydrates — results in the need to adjust the others to meet calorie needs.

In this study, people following lower-carbohydrate diets consumed higher amounts of fat and saturated fat. The substitution of fat calories — especially saturated fat — for carbohydrate calories resulted in significantly poorer control of blood glucose and need for higher insulin dose. Conversely, diets lower in total fat and saturated fat — and higher in carbs — were associated with better control. The authors refer to previous studies that also point to saturated fat as a possible mechanism behind the need for increased insulin and poorer control in the long run.

Intuitively we think that lowering carbohydrates should result in better control of diabetes. But what we may have overlooked is that by making this change we could end up increasing the intake of other nutrients with potentially adverse effects. For those with type 1 diabetes, this study makes the case that there's more to it than carbs: We also need to pay attention to fat and saturated fat.

More research is needed. How many carbs? How much fat? What about protein and alcohol? Moderate amounts for all? How do various foods fit into these diets and what is the result of the types of carbs (fiber) and fat (saturated, mono and polyunsaturated) that we eat? And what about vitamins, minerals and other nutrients? Furthermore, do different diets have different effects on control of type 1 and type 2 diabetes?

I believe wholeheartedly that there is no "one diet that fits all." It's important for those with diabetes to work with their health care providers to achieve optimal glycemic control — and to follow a healthy diet that's tailored to their needs.

Finally, to those who noted that 45% of calories from carbohydrates is not the definition of a low-carb diet, I agree. You'll notice that we've changed the title of the blogs to reflect this. However, the surprising thing in this study was that the mild reduction in carbs resulted in people eating diets that had enough total and saturated fat to require more insulin.

26 comments posted

blog index
References
  1. Delahanty LM, et. al. Association of diet with glycated hemoglobin during intensive treatment of type 1 diabetes in the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 2009;89:518.
  2. Djousse L, Gaziano JM. Egg consumption in relation to cardiovascular disease and mortality: The Physicians' Health Study. American Journal Clinical Nutrition. 2008;87:964.

MY00550

Feb. 3, 2009

© 1998-2009 Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and Research (MFMER). All rights reserved. A single copy of these materials may be reprinted for noncommercial personal use only. "Mayo," "Mayo Clinic," "MayoClinic.com," "EmbodyHealth," "Reliable tools for healthier lives," "Enhance your life," and the triple-shield Mayo Clinic logo are trademarks of Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and Research.


Text Size: smaller largerlarger